Released: April 12, 2005
Mudvayne had spent two albums proving how many moving parts they could fit inside one riff. By 2005, the harder job was deciding which parts a song actually needed. On Lost and Found, released April 12 with Dave Fortman producing, Chad Gray, Greg Tribbett, Ryan Martinie, and Matt McDonough tightened their writing while every player continued to pull at the edges. How much of Mudvayne’s strangeness survives once the songs have clearer destinations?
“Determined” gives a blunt first answer. Tribbett drives a short, grinding riff while McDonough’s double kick keeps the song moving at a near-thrash pace. Gray clips his words into the rhythm, then stretches the chorus into a hoarse rallying cry. At two minutes and thirty-nine seconds, there is no side route or long setup. Even Martinie, usually the member most likely to slip away from the guitar, works close to the main attack. The oddness has moved into the accents and the physical snap of the playing.
“Happy?” explains the album even better. The verse is built from a simple stop-start guitar figure, but Martinie refuses to treat it as space. His bass pops around the beat, and in the chorus he strikes octave pairs hard enough to create a second rhythmic layer beneath the open guitar chords. McDonough marks the turns with sharp kick patterns instead of flattening everything into a standard rock backbeat. The hook is immediate because the detail sits inside it.
That approach keeps the shorter songs recognizable. “Pushing Through” starts with a crooked riff that seems to trip over its own count before settling into a firm groove. “Forget to Remember” gives Gray room to move from a close, clenched verse into a clean chorus, while Tribbett shifts from muted notes to broad chords without cluttering the change. “Fall Into Sleep” opens with quiet guitar and a restrained vocal, then adds weight in stages. These arrangements are easy to follow, but the rhythm section keeps disturbing the straight lines.
The longer pieces give that complexity more room. “IMN” spends nearly six minutes breaking its central riff into bursts, pauses, and lurching tempo changes as Gray repeats “I’m no one” with increasing desperation. “Choices” takes eight minutes to work through clean passages, blunt grooves, childlike “eeny, meeny, miny, moe” voices, and a chorus that keeps returning in altered surroundings. The counting rhyme grates, but a childish method of making a decision belongs inside a song about personal freedom. Some parts run longer than they need to, though the idea remains unmistakably Mudvayne.
Fortman’s production makes the shift plain. Tribbett’s guitar has a dry, serrated edge, McDonough’s kick drums stay defined during the busiest patterns, and Martinie’s clank remains audible without dominating every section. Gray is pushed to the front, and the switches between his bark, whisper, and clean singing often replace another instrumental turn. Putting him this far forward also exposes the writing’s limits. Gray returns often to isolation, resentment, and self-erasure, narrowing the emotional range even when the music changes shape around him.
So how much of Mudvayne’s strangeness survives? Plenty. Lost and Found makes the choruses easier to locate and trims some of the detours, but “Happy?” still hides an octave-struck bass performance inside a radio hook, “Pushing Through” still bends the count, and “Choices” still spends eight minutes turning a children’s rhyme into an argument about free will. Mudvayne found clearer songs without teaching its four players to think in straight lines.
Written by Rob Joncas for DeadNoteMedia.
Artist information and music courtesy of the band.
© 2025 DeadNoteMedia. All rights reserved.
DeadNoteMedia 