Soundgarden – Down on the Upside: Soundgarden Sounded Like They Were Pulling Away

Released: May 21, 1996

Soundgarden did not come out of Superunknown sounding like they wanted to do it again.

That is what makes Down on the Upside interesting.

After Superunknown, they could have made the obvious follow-up. Bigger riffs. Bigger choruses. Another “Black Hole Sun” if they could find one. That would have made sense. The band had crossed over without fully sanding down what made them weird.

But Down on the Upside does not sound like a band chasing that moment.

It sounds like a band trying to get away from it.

So the question is simple: what happens when a band gets huge, then starts pulling at the edges of its sound?

Released in 1996, Down on the Upside was Soundgarden’s fifth album and the first one they produced themselves. That matters because the record feels less like a clean next step and more like four people trying to see how much space was still inside the band. Chris Cornell, Kim Thayil, Ben Shepherd, and Matt Cameron were still clearly Soundgarden, but the shape had changed.

“Pretty Noose” is a smart opener because it still gives you the band people recognize. The riff has that sideways Thayil feel, Cameron keeps everything moving without making it too straight, and Cornell sounds huge without turning the song into pure arena rock. It has a hook, but it also feels bent.

That is the album in a nutshell. Familiar, but not comfortable.

“Burden in My Hand” is probably the cleanest example of where Soundgarden were going. It is acoustic, but not soft. It offers space, but it still feels tense. Cornell sings it like a murder ballad that got left in the sun too long. The song is catchy enough for radio, but it doesn’t feel like it was made just for that.

That is the trick with this album. Even the accessible songs have dirt under them.

“Blow Up the Outside World” has one of Cornell’s biggest choruses, but the song starts small and tired before it opens up. It is not just loud-quiet-loud as a formula. It feels like someone trying not to explode and then doing it anyway. Soundgarden were always good at making heaviness feel physical, but here the pressure feels more internal.

The deeper cuts are where Down on the Upside really shows what it is doing. “Zero Chance” is one of the most underrated songs in the band’s catalog. It does not need to crush anything. It just sits there, sad and strange, with Shepherd’s writing giving the album a different pull. “Tighter & Tighter” stretches out and gets almost hypnotic. “Overfloater” drifts without losing the riff. These are not songs trying to win people over fast. They take their time.

Then you get “Ty Cobb,” which sounds like the band kicking over a chair just to make sure nobody got too relaxed. It is acoustic punk with teeth, messy in the right way, and it keeps the album from sinking too far into its own mood. Soundgarden could be heavy, weird, funny, ugly, and beautiful on the same record. Down on the Upside lets all of that sit together.

That is also why the album can feel uneven. It is long. It wanders. Some songs feel like they are following their own weather. But that is part of why it still feels alive. A tighter version might have been easier to sell, but it would not say as much about where the band was.

This does not sound like a band breaking up in some dramatic movie-scene way. It sounds more like a band whose members are starting to look in different directions while still speaking the same language. Cornell is leaning more melodic and personal. Thayil still brings the strange guitar angles. Shepherd adds rougher, looser colours. Cameron holds the whole thing together because that is what Matt Cameron does.

The title fits better the longer the album goes. Down on the Upside sounds like success turned inside out. The band had reached the top, but the music does not sound victorious. It sounds restless. It sounds tired of the obvious move.

So what happens when a band gets huge, then starts pulling at the edges of its own sound?

You get Down on the Upside. Not Superunknown again. Not a collapse. Not a victory lap. It is Soundgarden trying to stay strange after the world had already decided what version of them it wanted.

The album works because it does not chase the big moment.

It walks away from it, slowly, with the amps still on.

Share this:

Related